How to Know if Your Workout Is Working (and When to Change)
By CoachAk · · 8 min read
Here is how to know if your workout is working: look at four records together, over two to three months, rather than at how one session felt. If the weights or reps on your main lifts are going up, your tape measurements and photos are moving the way you want, and your weekly average weight matches your goal, the program is working, even if it feels slow. Soreness, sweat and a pump tell you very little.
How to know if your workout is working: the short answer
- Your training log shows more weight or more reps on the same exercises than a month or two ago, with the same form.
- Your tape measure shows your waist smaller if you are losing fat, or steady to slowly rising if you are building muscle, with your arms, chest and thighs slowly bigger.
- Your photos show a change when you compare them a month or more apart, taken the same way each time.
- Your weekly average weight is moving at the rate your goal calls for.
- Give it time. Strength often rises within weeks, but allow about 8 to 12 weeks of steady training before judging how much muscle a program is building.
If two or three of the four records are moving the right way, keep going. If none have moved after a couple of months of consistent training, check the basics further down before you change the whole program.
What does not tell you much
Soreness. Being sore the next day feels like proof, but it is a poor guide. Soreness tends to be strongest when an exercise or a workload is new to you, and it usually fades as you repeat it, so feeling less sore does not mean a muscle has stopped growing. A workout can build muscle without leaving you sore.
The pump. The tight, full feeling during a session is temporary swelling that fades after you finish. Enjoyable, but not evidence.
Feeling wrecked. A session that leaves you exhausted is not automatically a better one. Fatigue is easy to create; progress is not.
One weigh-in. Your weight can jump or drop overnight with water, salt, carbohydrate and the food in your gut. How to read the scale explains why the weekly average is the number to trust.
Sign 1: your training log is moving
This is the clearest sign, and the one you can check most often. Muscle is built by asking it to do a little more over time, so a slowly climbing log is the best day-to-day evidence that the program is doing its job.
Compare like with like: the same exercise, the same rep range, the same form and roughly the same rest. Then compare your best working set now with the same set four to eight weeks ago. Any of these counts as progress:
- More reps with the same weight.
- More weight for the same reps.
- The same weight and reps with reps to spare, for example a set that used to leave you one rep short of failure now leaves you three short.
One caution: strength is partly a skill. Beginners in particular get stronger quickly as they learn a movement, before much new muscle shows. So a rising log is a good sign, but pair it with the tape measure and photos before you decide how much muscle you are building.
Sign 2: your tape measurements
A tape measure picks up changes the mirror misses. Every two to four weeks, measure your waist, chest, upper arm and thigh (and hips if you like):
- First thing in the morning, before eating.
- Relaxed, not flexed. For the waist, measure around your belly button after breathing out.
- At the same spot every time, with the tape level and snug but not digging in.
- Twice at each spot, using the average.
What "working" looks like depends on your goal:
| Goal | Waist | Arms, chest, thighs | Weekly average weight |
|---|---|---|---|
| Building muscle (lean bulk) | Steady, or creeping up slowly | Slowly bigger | Rising about 1 to 1.5% a month for beginners, 0.5 to 1% for intermediates, up to 0.5% for advanced lifters |
| Losing fat | Smaller | Steady or a little smaller as fat comes off | Falling about 0.5 to 1% a week |
| Recomposition | Smaller | Steady or slowly bigger | Flat or falling slowly |
On a fat-loss phase, your arms and thighs may shrink a little because some of what you are measuring is fat. Holding your strength is a good sign you are keeping your muscle.
Sign 3: your photos
Changes in muscle are small from week to week, which is exactly why photos help. Take them every four weeks or so, in the same light, at the same time of day, from the same distance, relaxed and in the same poses. Then compare the newest photo with your oldest, not with last month's. A slow change is much easier to see over three months than over three weeks.
Sign 4: your weekly average weight
Weigh yourself every morning, after the toilet and before eating or drinking, and work out the average for each week. Then compare it with the rate in the table above.
- Building muscle, but your average has been flat for two to three weeks? You are probably not eating enough to grow. Most people who are not beginners need a small calorie surplus to build muscle at a decent pace.
- Gaining much faster than the target? More of that weight is likely to be fat. Am I gaining muscle or fat? shows how to read your weight, waist, lifts and photos together.
- Losing fat, and the average is falling at about 0.5 to 1% a week while your lifts hold? That is a program and a diet working together.
How long before you can tell?
Strength moves first: within a few weeks of starting a new program, most people see their numbers rise as they learn the exercises. Muscle growth is slower, and small changes are hard to see in the mirror or on a tape measure.
There is no tested rule for how long to wait, so this is common coaching practice: give a program about 8 to 12 weeks of consistent training before you judge how much muscle it is building. That is usually long enough for a real change to show in your measurements and photos, and short enough that you do not waste months on something that is not working.
If you have been training for years, expect even slower changes: a small change on the tape over a few months can be real progress.
Everyone responds at a different speed
People respond to the same training very differently. In a 2005 study by Hubal and colleagues in Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, 585 men and women followed the same 12-week arm-training program. Changes in the size of the trained muscle, measured by MRI scans, ranged from a 2% loss to a 59% gain, and strength gains ranged from none at all to 250%.
That is why comparing yourself with a training partner, or with someone online, is a poor test of your program. Compare yourself with yourself, three months ago.
Not working? Check these before you change program
If your log, tape, photos and weight have all been flat for two months or more, the program itself is not always the problem. Check these first, roughly in this order:
- Consistency. Did you do most of the planned sessions, most weeks? A good program done half the time is a half-good program.
- Effort. Most of your working sets should end about 1 to 3 reps short of failure. Sets that stop far from failure may be too easy to build much muscle.
- Progression. Are you actually trying to add reps or weight, or repeating the same numbers every week?
- Volume. About 10 to 20 hard sets per muscle a week is a sensible range for most people. Very few sets may not be enough.
- Food. Protein of about 1.6 to 2.2 g per kg of body weight a day, and enough calories for your goal. Building muscle while eating well below maintenance is slow for most people past the beginner stage.
- Sleep and stress. Short sleep and a hard few months at work can stall progress on any program.
If all of those are in place and nothing has moved in two to three months, change one thing at a time: add a couple of sets for a lagging muscle, swap an exercise that hurts or that you cannot progress on, or adjust your calories. Changing everything at once means you never learn what worked. Not building muscle? goes through the common causes in more detail.
If an exercise causes pain that does not settle, or you have a health condition that affects your training, speak to your doctor or a physiotherapist before pushing on.
What to check, and how often
| What | How often | Working looks like |
|---|---|---|
| Training log | Every session; review monthly | More reps or weight on the same lifts |
| Body weight | Daily, judged as a weekly average | Moving at your goal's target rate |
| Tape measurements | Every 2 to 4 weeks | Waist down on a cut, steady or slowly up on a bulk; limbs slowly up if building |
| Photos | Every 4 weeks or so | Visible change against your oldest photo |
How coaching helps
The hard part is rarely collecting the numbers. It is reading them honestly, and knowing whether a flat month means a bad program, a busy month or simply slow progress. With one-to-one coaching from CoachAk, your program sets out the exercises, sets, reps, effort targets and rest times, and you log every workout in the app, which shows your personal bests and what you lifted last time. Your coach can comment on your sessions and reply to form-check videos.
You log your weight daily and see a smoothed trend, and each week you send a check-in of about three minutes covering your weight, training and nutrition adherence, steps, sleep, energy, hunger, stress and digestion, with optional body measurements and photos. Your coach replies with written feedback on what is working, what changes next and why, and adjusts your plan when the evidence says so, not after one bad week.
If you want someone reading those numbers with you, apply for coaching.
Free newsletter
New articles, straight to your inbox
Get new CoachAk articles by email: training, nutrition, contest prep and health, explained plainly.
Free. Unsubscribe any time. Your email address is used only for this newsletter, is never sold, and is not shared with anyone else unless the law requires it. Privacy policy