Not Seeing Results With a Personal Trainer? What to Check

By CoachAk · · 6 min read

Not seeing results with personal trainer sessions you are paying for is frustrating, and it is tempting to blame either the trainer or yourself. Usually the answer sits somewhere in between. A few hours a week with a trainer is a small part of your week, and what happens in the rest of it (food, daily movement, sleep, the sessions you do alone) decides much of what happens to fat and muscle. Check those first, then check whether anyone is measuring your progress at all. If all of that is in order and nothing has changed for months, it is time for an honest conversation about the training itself.

The short answer

Work through these in order:

  1. What happens between sessions: how often you train, how much you move, how many sessions you miss.
  2. Food: calories that match your goal and enough protein, tracked honestly.
  3. Sleep and stress.
  4. Your timeline: is the change you expected realistic for the time so far?
  5. Tracking: is anyone recording your lifts, weight trend, measurements or photos?
  6. Then the training itself: is it planned, progressing and aimed at your goal?

Not seeing results with personal trainer sessions? Check these first

1. The rest of the week

Three one-hour sessions cover three of the 168 hours in a week. A trainer can make those hours count, but cannot see the rest. Be honest about:

  • How often you train, with or without your trainer. The NHS advises strength training on at least 2 days a week, and for building muscle, a 2017 meta-analysis by Schoenfeld, Ogborn and Krieger linked 10 or more hard sets per muscle per week with more growth than fewer than 5. One session a week can struggle to reach that.
  • How much you move outside the gym. A daily step count is an easy thing to check.
  • How many sessions you have missed in the last two months.

2. Food

For fat loss, you need to eat less than you burn; to build muscle, you need enough food and protein. Both are decided outside the session, and it is easy to eat more than you think. In a small 1992 study in the New England Journal of Medicine, Lichtman and colleagues found that people who believed they could not lose weight on low calories were under-reporting what they ate by an average of 47%, and over-reporting their physical activity by 51%.

Try two weeks of honest tracking, weighing food where you can, before deciding your body does not respond. Aim for about 1.6 to 2.2 g of protein per kg of body weight a day, the range a 2018 meta-analysis by Morton and colleagues found covers most people. The free calorie and macro calculator gives you a starting point, and why am I not losing weight? goes through the common reasons fat loss stalls.

3. Sleep and stress

Short sleep works against you. In a small two-week study by Nedeltcheva and colleagues (2010, Annals of Internal Medicine), dieters who spent 5.5 hours in bed rather than 8.5 lost a similar amount of weight, but 55% less fat. The American Academy of Sleep Medicine recommends at least 7 hours a night for adults. If poor sleep or stress keeps going for weeks, speak to your GP.

4. Your timeline

A fair result depends on your goal and your starting point. As a rough guide:

Goal A realistic pace
Fat loss About 0.5 to 1% of body weight a week
Building muscle, beginner About 1 to 1.5% of body weight a month on the scale
Building muscle, intermediate About 0.5 to 1% a month
Building muscle, advanced Up to about 0.5% a month

The fat-loss rate is the one Helms and colleagues (2014) recommend for keeping muscle while dieting. The muscle-gain rates are common coaching targets, and not all of that weight is muscle.

People also vary widely. In a 2005 study by Hubal and colleagues (Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise), 585 men and women followed the same 12-week arm-training program, and changes in muscle size ranged from a 2% loss to a 59% gain. Six weeks of sessions may simply not be long enough to see much in the mirror. If your goal is muscle, not building muscle? covers the common reasons it stalls.

5. Is anything being measured?

If nobody is recording your lifts, weight trend, waist or photos, nobody can tell whether the plan is working. Progress can also hide: you can lose fat and gain muscle while the scale barely moves.

Measuring helps in its own right. A 2016 meta-analysis by Harkin and colleagues (Psychological Bulletin), pooling 138 studies, found that monitoring progress made people more likely to reach their goals, especially when progress was recorded or reported to someone else. Start now:

  • write down the weight and reps of your main lifts every session;
  • weigh yourself each morning and compare weekly averages;
  • measure your waist every two to four weeks;
  • take photos in the same light and pose every few weeks.

Signs the training itself needs to change

If the checklist above is in good shape and nothing has moved for two or three months, look at the training. These are things to raise with your trainer, not proof that they are doing a bad job:

  • The weights and reps have barely changed in months, with no plan for when they will. A trainer's presence should help you push: in a 2000 study by Mazzetti and colleagues (Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise), men who trained one-to-one with a personal trainer for 12 weeks increased their training loads faster, and gained more strength, than men who followed the same program without supervision.
  • Sessions feel random, with no program linking one week to the next.
  • Nobody records what you lift.
  • Your goal has not come up since the first session, or the training does not match it.
  • There is no plan for the days between sessions, or for food, and no suggestion of where to get that help.
  • Pain is brushed off. Pain that does not settle needs your GP or a physiotherapist, not more sets.

Talk to your trainer first

Most trainers want you to get results, and plenty of problems clear up after one honest conversation. Bring your numbers and ask:

  • What is the plan for the next 8 to 12 weeks, and how will we know it is working?
  • How will we track my progress?
  • What should I do on the days I do not see you?
  • Can you help with food, or who should I see? If you have a medical condition that affects what you eat, a registered dietitian working with your doctor is the right person.

If the answers are vague, or nothing changes after a few more weeks, it may be time for a different kind of help.

Choosing a different kind of help

What you need depends on what the checklist showed:

  • If the problem is technique, or turning up at all, a personal trainer is often still the right fit, and a fresh pair of eyes may help.
  • If the problem is everything outside the session (food, steps, consistency and knowing what to change), an online coach who writes your plan and reviews it every week may suit you better.
  • Some people combine both: a trainer for technique, a coach for the plan and nutrition. Only one person should write your program, so tell each what the other is doing.

Online coach vs personal trainer compares the two in detail.

How coaching helps

With one-to-one online coaching from CoachAk, the hours outside the gym are part of the plan. Your training program is written for you, and your calorie, macro and step targets sit alongside it in a private app. You log your workouts, with your personal bests and your coach's comments, and your daily weight. Each week you send a check-in that takes about three minutes, covering your weight, training and nutrition adherence, steps, sleep, energy, hunger and stress, with optional measurements and photos. CoachAk replies with written feedback on what changes next week and why, and you can message your coach directly, with photos and voice notes, or send form-check videos for feedback on your technique. It is online coaching, so nobody stands beside you in the gym.

If you have worked through the checklist and want a plan that covers the whole week, apply for coaching.

Share this article:

WhatsAppFacebookXEmail

Free newsletter

New articles, straight to your inbox

Get new CoachAk articles by email: training, nutrition, contest prep and health, explained plainly.

Free. Unsubscribe any time. Your email address is used only for this newsletter, is never sold, and is not shared with anyone else unless the law requires it. Privacy policy