Should I Compete in Bodybuilding? Honest Pros and Cons
By CoachAk · · 6 min read
Should I compete in bodybuilding? If you are asking, here is the honest answer: compete if you want the experience itself, have a few years of steady training behind you, can give several months to a strict diet and several more to recovering from it, and have a healthy relationship with food. Think twice if you hope a show will fix how you feel about your body, or if food and weight have been a struggle for you in the past. Here are the real pros and cons, and the questions worth answering before you decide.
The short answer
What a show can give you:
- A fixed date and a clear goal, which makes it easier to stay consistent.
- A first-hand lesson in how your body responds to a long diet.
- New skills: posing, stage presence, and planning months ahead.
- An outside, if subjective, verdict on your physique, and people who share the interest.
What it costs:
- Months of strict dieting and training, with hunger and low energy towards the end.
- Money: entry fees, membership, tan, outfit, travel, food and often coaching.
- Effects on your body that can last for months after the show.
- Strain on your mood, your relationship with food and the people around you.
What you can gain from competing
A goal that will not move. A date on the calendar changes how you train and eat. A fixed deadline can make consistency much easier than a vague wish to "get in shape".
Knowing how your body responds. You find out what it takes for you to get really lean, how your hunger, energy and strength change, and what you look like at your leanest. That knowledge is useful long after the show.
A new skill. Posing is harder than it looks, and presenting yourself on stage in front of judges and an audience takes nerve. Learning to do both can be a real source of confidence.
An honest benchmark. Standing next to other competitors shows you where you are strong and what to work on. Judging is subjective, but it is still feedback.
Community. Shows, posing classes and gyms full of people prepping can be a sociable world to be part of.
None of this is guaranteed, and nobody, coach included, can promise you a placing.
What competing really costs
Time
A prep is long. In a 2017 study in Frontiers in Physiology, Hulmi and colleagues followed 27 women preparing for bikini and other fitness classes. Their diets lasted about 20 weeks on average. During that time they lifted about 4 to 5 times a week, in sessions of 40 to 90 minutes, and their cardio sessions rose from about 3.6 a week to about 4.9 near the end.
Add posing practice, meal preparation, weighing food, check-ins and the show day itself. Then add recovery: the study followed the women for about four months after their shows, and some measures had still not returned to where they started.
Money
The costs vary a lot by country, federation and how far you travel, so add up your own before you commit. Typical items include:
- federation membership and entry fees, sometimes for each class you enter,
- your tan, suit or trunks, and heels for bikini,
- posing lessons,
- travel and a hotel near the show,
- extra food, and often a coach.
Your body
Getting to stage condition means dieting far leaner than everyday life, and your body notices. In Hulmi's study:
- body weight fell by about 12% on average, and DXA-measured body fat from about 23% to 13%,
- 63% of the dieting women reported irregular periods during the diet, against 30% of a comparison group who were not dieting,
- levels of several hormones fell, and about four months after the show, thyroid hormone (T3) and testosterone were still slightly below where they started,
- body weight had almost returned to its starting point by then, while body fat had partly recovered.
If your periods stop or change during a diet, speak to your doctor. If you have a health condition, take regular medication, have an injury or are pregnant, speak to your doctor or GP before you start a prep. Never stop or change a prescribed medicine to compete.
Your mind and the people around you
Late in a prep, hunger, tiredness and constant thoughts about food are common. The mood questionnaires in Hulmi's study did not show significant changes, so not everyone struggles in the same way. Even so, a long diet can be hard on your patience, sleep, social life and relationships. Some people find the weeks after a show harder still, when weight returns and stage photos become an unfair comparison.
If you have a history of disordered eating, or you notice that food, weight or your appearance is taking over your thoughts, speak to your doctor or GP before going further.
Drugs in untested shows
Some federations and shows are drug-tested, often called "natural"; others are not. In untested shows, some competitors use anabolic steroids and other performance-enhancing drugs, and the health risks are real. Competing untested does not mean you have to use anything. If you are considering it, speak to your doctor first and read steroids and PEDs: the health risks, which also covers the law and why bloodwork matters.
Should I compete in bodybuilding? Questions to ask yourself
Answer these honestly, ideally on paper:
- Why do I want to do this? "To see what I can do" and "because I love training" are good reasons. "Because I will finally like my body" usually is not.
- How long have I trained consistently? Muscle carries a physique on stage. How long to train before competing covers how to tell if you have enough.
- Have I dieted successfully before? A well-run cut is the best rehearsal for a prep.
- Can my next 6 to 12 months take it? Think about work, family, holidays, weddings and money.
- How do I feel about food? If dieting has caused you real distress before, take that seriously.
- Would I be glad I did it even if I placed last? If not, the result is carrying too much weight.
- What will I do after the show? Plan the recovery before you start the diet.
Signs it is not the right time
- You are in your first year or two of training and still making fast progress.
- You have never followed a diet for more than a few weeks.
- You have a current injury, a health condition that is not under control, or you are pregnant or planning to be. Speak to your doctor or GP first.
- A big life event, such as a new job, a house move or a new baby, falls inside the prep.
- You have a history of an eating disorder and have not spoken to your doctor about competing.
Waiting a year is not failing. It usually means you arrive with more muscle and a better idea of how to diet.
If you are still undecided
You do not have to commit to a show to learn whether you would enjoy one:
- Go and watch a show in the federation you are thinking about.
- Read the rules for your division, and practise the poses at home. Your first bodybuilding competition explains divisions and federations.
- Run a proper cut of 12 weeks or so, with weekly photos and posing practice, and see how you handle it.
- Pick a show far enough away that you could stop without losing much. The free contest prep calculator estimates how long you would need.
How coaching helps
Coaching cannot decide for you, and it cannot promise a result. What it can do is give you an honest outside view of where you are and plan a prep that does not rely on crash dieting at the end.
When you apply, CoachAk reads every application personally and will tell you honestly whether coaching is the right fit. With one-to-one coaching, your training program and nutrition targets are written for you in a private app and adjusted as your body responds. Each week you send a check-in that takes about three minutes, covering your weight, training and nutrition adherence, steps, sleep, energy, hunger and stress, with optional measurements and progress photos compared side by side. You get written feedback, and you can message your coach directly between check-ins.
If you are weighing up your first show, apply for coaching, or read more about contest prep coaching.
Free newsletter
New articles, straight to your inbox
Get new CoachAk articles by email: training, nutrition, contest prep and health, explained plainly.
Free. Unsubscribe any time. Your email address is used only for this newsletter, is never sold, and is not shared with anyone else unless the law requires it. Privacy policy