Best Supplements for Muscle Growth, Ranked by Evidence

By CoachAk · · 7 min read

Not medical advice. This article is general information to help you ask better questions. Talk to your doctor before starting, stopping or changing any medicine, drug or supplement, and about any symptoms. Anything it says about the law is a summary, not legal advice, and may be out of date.

The best supplements for muscle growth are a short list: creatine monohydrate, and protein powder if it helps you reach your daily protein target. Caffeine can help you train harder. Almost everything else sold for muscle has weak evidence, no evidence, or evidence that it does nothing for someone who already eats enough protein. The International Olympic Committee's consensus statement on supplements (Maughan and colleagues, 2018) concluded that only a few supplements have good evidence of improving performance.

Here is how the popular options sort out, so you can spend your money on the few that matter.

The short answer

Verdict Supplement Why
Worth it Creatine monohydrate The best-supported supplement for strength and lean mass
Worth it Protein powder Helps you reach your protein target when food alone falls short
Worth it, for training Caffeine Improves performance; does not build muscle itself
Maybe Vitamin D For health if you are low, not as a muscle builder
Skip BCAAs Unlikely to add anything if you already eat enough protein
Skip HMB Pooled trials in young people found no real benefit
Skip "Testosterone boosters" Claims mostly not backed by research

None of these replaces a program that progresses, enough food, enough protein and enough sleep. Supplements add a little on top of those. Without the basics, they have nothing to add to.

Best supplements for muscle growth: the ones worth buying

Creatine monohydrate

Creatine helps your muscles rebuild energy quickly during short, hard efforts, so you can squeeze out an extra rep or two. Over weeks and months, that extra work adds up to more strength and muscle.

The International Society of Sports Nutrition's position stand (Kreider and colleagues, 2017) calls creatine monohydrate the most effective nutritional supplement available for increasing high-intensity exercise capacity and lean body mass, and concludes it is safe for healthy people used as recommended. The IOC consensus also lists it among the few supplements with good evidence.

The usual amount is 3 to 5 g a day, every day. Plain monohydrate is the form used in the research and the cheapest; pricier forms have not been shown to work better. If you have kidney disease, speak to your doctor first. Creatine: what it does and doesn't do covers loading, water weight and the myths.

Protein powder

Protein powder is food in a convenient form, not a special muscle builder. Its value is helping you reach your daily protein target when meals alone fall short.

The key study here is a 2018 meta-analysis by Morton and colleagues (British Journal of Sports Medicine): 49 trials, 1,863 people, all doing resistance training. Adding protein supplements increased gains in:

  • Fat-free mass by about 0.3 kg (0.7 lb) on average,
  • One-rep max strength by about 2.5 kg (5.5 lb) on average.

The benefit was bigger in people who were already trained and smaller in older people. It also levelled off once total protein intake reached about 1.6 g per kg of body weight a day. Above that, extra protein did not add more fat-free mass. If you already eat that much from food, a shake adds convenience, not muscle.

The upper end of the study's estimate was about 2.2 g/kg, which is why the usual target is 1.6 to 2.2 g per kg a day: the top of the range covers people who need more, such as anyone on a fat-loss diet. How much protein you need to build muscle explains how to set your number, and the free protein calculator does it for you.

Whey is the most common choice, and a 2018 meta-analysis by Messina and colleagues found that soy protein gave similar gains in strength and lean mass to whey and other animal proteins. Pick one you like and can afford.

Caffeine, for training rather than muscle

Caffeine does not build muscle, but it can help you train harder, which is what drives growth. The International Society of Sports Nutrition's caffeine position stand (Guest and colleagues, 2021) concludes it improves many kinds of exercise performance, typically at 3 to 6 mg per kg of body weight taken about an hour before training. More is not better: higher amounts mostly add side effects.

Coffee counts too, though the amount of caffeine in a cup varies. The catch is sleep: caffeine late in the day can cut your sleep short and cost more than it gives. If you have a heart condition, high blood pressure or are pregnant, speak to your doctor or midwife about caffeine.

Maybe: depends on you

Vitamin D

Vitamin D matters for your health, but it is not a muscle builder. The NHS advises everyone in the UK to consider a daily vitamin D supplement in autumn and winter, when there is not enough sunlight to make it in the skin. If you think you might be low, ask your GP rather than taking large amounts on your own.

"Pre-workout" products

Many are built around caffeine, plus a mix of other ingredients. Check how much caffeine a serving contains, avoid products that hide amounts behind a "proprietary blend", and remember that the caffeine is usually the part doing the work.

Skip: little or no evidence for muscle

BCAAs and other amino acid drinks

Branched-chain amino acids (leucine, isoleucine and valine) are three of the nine essential amino acids. Your body needs all nine to build muscle, and every protein-rich meal or shake already contains BCAAs along with the other six.

Reviewing the human research in 2017 (Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition), Robert Wolfe concluded that BCAA supplements alone do not promote muscle building, because muscle needs all the essential amino acids to grow. And in the Morton meta-analysis, even whole-protein supplements stopped adding fat-free mass once total protein reached about 1.6 g per kg a day, so there is little reason to expect a partial protein to do better. If you want more muscle-building amino acids, eat more protein.

HMB

HMB is made in the body from leucine and is sold to build muscle and speed recovery. A 2020 meta-analysis by Jakubowski and colleagues (Nutrients) pooled 11 trials in young people doing resistance training. HMB gave no significant extra gain in fat-free mass or strength compared with a placebo, and the authors concluded the findings do not support using it to improve body composition or strength.

"Testosterone boosters"

A 2020 study by Clemesha and colleagues (World Journal of Men's Health) looked at 50 popular testosterone-boosting supplements. About 90% claimed to raise testosterone, but the published research on their ingredients mostly did not back that up, and for some it showed a decrease. If you are worried about low testosterone, see your doctor for a blood test.

Mass gainers

These are a mix of carbohydrate and protein in a large serving: extra calories in a shake, with nothing in them that food does not provide. They can be handy if you genuinely struggle to eat enough, but milk, oats, peanut butter and a banana in a blender do the same job.

Supplements are not checked like medicines

Supplements are not medicines, and they are not checked like medicines before they go on sale. In the US, the Food and Drug Administration says it does not have the authority to approve dietary supplements before they are marketed; the companies that make and sell them are responsible for their safety.

Contamination is a real risk too. The IOC consensus cites a study in which about 15% of more than 600 supplements bought around the world contained undeclared prohormones, substances related to steroids, and notes that the problem has not gone away. The IOC warns that a tiny amount of contamination can be enough to fail a drug test.

To lower the risk:

  • Choose third-party tested products. Schemes that batch-test supplements for banned substances help, though the IOC is clear there is no absolute guarantee.
  • Be wary of anything sold as "anabolic" or promising steroid-like results. If it works like a drug, it may contain one.
  • If you compete in a tested federation, the responsibility is yours. Natural bodybuilding drug testing explains how testing works.
  • If you take any medicine, have a health condition or are pregnant, speak to your doctor or pharmacist before taking a supplement.

Where your money goes furthest

If you have a fixed budget, spend it in this order:

  1. Enough food and protein for your goal, every day.
  2. A program that progresses, with sets taken about 1 to 3 reps short of failure.
  3. Sleep, which costs nothing.
  4. Creatine monohydrate, which costs little.
  5. Protein powder, only if you struggle to reach your target from food.

Everything after that is optional at best.

How coaching helps

Supplements are the easy part to buy and the least important part of the result. With one-to-one coaching from CoachAk, your training program and your calorie, protein and macro targets are set for you in a private app. You log every workout, see your personal bests, and send a weekly check-in covering your weight, training and nutrition adherence, sleep, energy and hunger. Your coach replies with written feedback and adjusts your plan, so the basics that build muscle actually get done.

If you want the program and nutrition right before you spend money on extras, apply for coaching.

Share this article:

WhatsAppFacebookXEmail

Free newsletter

New articles, straight to your inbox

Get new CoachAk articles by email: training, nutrition, contest prep and health, explained plainly.

Free. Unsubscribe any time. Your email address is used only for this newsletter, is never sold, and is not shared with anyone else unless the law requires it. Privacy policy