Flexible Dieting (IIFYM): Does It Work for Fat Loss?

By CoachAk · · 6 min read

Flexible dieting means hitting your calorie and protein targets (or all your macros) with foods you choose, rather than following a fixed list of "clean" foods. It is often called IIFYM, short for "if it fits your macros". Does flexible dieting work for fat loss? Yes: in a trial in lifters, it worked as well as a strict meal plan, and flexible attitudes to food are linked with lower body weight and less binge eating. But flexible does not mean anything goes. It works best with sensible staples and a plan for the foods you love.

Flexible dieting: the short answer

  • Fat loss comes from a calorie deficit, not from cutting out particular foods.
  • In a 2021 trial in lifters, a flexible macro-counting diet and a strict meal plan gave similar fat loss.
  • In questionnaire studies, a flexible approach to eating goes with lower body weight and less binge eating; a rigid, all-or-nothing approach goes with more.
  • Food quality still matters for hunger, health and training, so most of your food should still be protein, fruit, vegetables and fibre-rich carbohydrates.
  • The best diet is the one you can keep doing. For many people that means a flexible one.

What flexible dieting is, and what it is not

The phrase is used in two ways.

As a method, flexible dieting or IIFYM means tracking calories and macros and letting yourself choose the foods. Pizza can fit, as long as it fits the numbers.

As a mindset, researchers call it "flexible restraint": you aim to eat less, but you adjust rather than ban. If lunch was bigger than planned, you eat a little less at dinner. The opposite is "rigid restraint": strict rules, forbidden foods, and the feeling that one biscuit has "ruined" the day, so you may as well carry on.

Flexible dieting is not:

  • eating whatever you like and hoping it works out,
  • building every day around sweets because they technically fit,
  • or ignoring protein and fibre.

Flexible vs rigid dieting: what the research shows

The trial in lifters. In a 2021 study in the Journal of the International Society of Sports Nutrition, Conlin and colleagues randomly put resistance-trained adults on a 10-week diet aiming for about 25% below maintenance. Both groups aimed for 2 g of protein per kg of body weight a day.

  • The flexible group got daily protein, carbohydrate and fat targets and were encouraged to eat a wide variety of foods.
  • The rigid group got a meal plan from a registered dietitian and were told not to swap anything.

Both groups lost weight and fat, with no significant difference between them: about 2.6 kg (5.7 lb) of weight and 2.3 kg (5.1 lb) of fat in the flexible group, and about 3.0 kg (6.6 lb) and 3.2 kg (7.1 lb) in the rigid group. The study was small: 39 people started and only 23 finished. In the 10 weeks after the diet, when everyone ate freely, the flexible group gained lean mass. The authors could not say why, and the two groups did not differ significantly in fat regained.

Questionnaire studies. Most of the research looks at the flexible and rigid mindsets rather than a particular diet:

  • Westenhöfer and colleagues (1999) used questionnaires and food diaries from 54,517 people in a computer-assisted weight-loss program and a random sample of 1,838 people in West Germany. Flexible control went with lower body weight, less binge eating and a greater chance of successful weight loss over the one-year program. Rigid control went with higher body weight and more frequent and severe binge eating.
  • Stewart and colleagues (2002) surveyed 188 women without obesity. Rigid dieting was linked with eating disorder symptoms, mood problems and strong worry about body size or shape. Flexible dieting was not strongly linked with any of these.
  • Westenhöfer and colleagues (2013) followed 106 women who had already lost weight at a slimming club. Over six months, flexible restraint went with more weight loss and better maintenance; rigid restraint went with less weight loss and more preoccupying thoughts about food.

These are questionnaire studies, so they show links, not cause and effect. People who find dieting easy may simply be more flexible. But the pattern is consistent, and it fits with the trial: you do not need a rigid plan to lose fat, and rigid rules carry risks.

Does flexible dieting mean eating junk food?

No. The calories decide whether you lose fat. The International Society of Sports Nutrition's 2017 position stand on diets and body composition (Aragon and colleagues) states that diets focused on fat loss are driven by a sustained calorie deficit. But what you eat decides how hungry you are, how well you train and how healthy the diet is.

A sensible flexible diet still has:

  • Enough protein: 1.6 to 2.2 g per kg of body weight a day, towards the top on a cut.
  • Plenty of fibre. UK government guidelines suggest 30 g a day for adults; fruit, vegetables, beans, oats and wholegrains get you there.
  • Mostly filling foods, because the same calories from lean meat, potatoes and vegetables usually keep you fuller than they do from crisps and chocolate. How to stop feeling hungry on a diet explains why.

Flexible dieting gives you room for the foods you love. It does not ask you to live on them.

How to fit foods you enjoy into a fat loss diet

  1. Set your calories and protein first. Everything else is built around those. Macros for cutting shows how.
  2. Build most meals from staples you like: a protein, a fruit or vegetable, and a carbohydrate. Repeat the ones that work.
  3. Leave a small share of the day for foods you enjoy. Many people keep something like 10 to 20% of their calories for treats. That is a common rule of thumb, not a tested number, so adjust it to what keeps you on track.
  4. Plan treats in advance and log them first. Deciding at breakfast that tonight's dessert fits is very different from deciding at 10pm.
  5. Swap "never" for "how much and how often". "Chocolate after dinner most nights, one bar" is a rule you can keep. "No chocolate ever" rarely survives a bad week.
  6. If you go over, carry on at the next meal. One meal over target is a small blip. Starving yourself the next day to make up for it can start the cycle again.
  7. Be honest about trigger foods. If one food reliably leads to eating the whole packet, keeping it out of the house for now is a sensible choice, not a failure of flexibility.

When flexible dieting is not the right fit

  • When counting itself becomes the problem. If tracking makes you anxious or obsessive, a simpler approach, such as set meal times and a hand-sized portion of protein at each meal, may suit you better.
  • When you prefer fewer decisions. Some people find a set meal plan easier. In the Conlin trial, both worked. Pick the one you will keep doing. How to stick to a diet covers what helps.
  • If you have, or have had, an eating disorder, or you binge regularly, speak to your doctor or GP before starting any diet or food tracking.

How coaching helps

Flexible dieting works best when someone helps you find the balance between freedom and structure, and spots when "it fits my macros" is drifting into "it fits, roughly".

With one-to-one coaching from CoachAk, your calorie and macro targets sit in a private app alongside your training program. Each weekly check-in takes about three minutes and covers your weight, nutrition adherence, hunger, energy and more. Your coach replies with written feedback and adjusts your targets as you go, and you can message your coach with photos of meals or menus when you are not sure how something fits.

If you want a coach to set your targets and adjust them with you each week, apply for coaching.

Share this article:

WhatsAppFacebookXEmail

Free newsletter

New articles, straight to your inbox

Get new CoachAk articles by email: training, nutrition, contest prep and health, explained plainly.

Free. Unsubscribe any time. Your email address is used only for this newsletter, is never sold, and is not shared with anyone else unless the law requires it. Privacy policy