How to Stick to a Diet: What the Research Says

By CoachAk · · 7 min read

The best diet is the one you can keep doing. In research comparing popular diets, how closely people stuck to their diet predicted their results far better than which diet they were on. So learning how to stick to a diet is worth more than hunting for the perfect one. The good news is that sticking to a diet can be learned, and there are tested ways to get better at it.

How to stick to a diet: the short answer

  • Choose a diet you could live with, built from foods you like, with a moderate deficit.
  • Plan the hard moments in advance with simple "if this happens, then I will..." plans.
  • Track something, such as your weight or your food, consistently.
  • Turn the key actions into habits by doing them at the same time and in the same place each day.
  • Drop all-or-nothing rules. One meal over target is a blip, not a failure.
  • Keep hunger manageable with protein, fibre and enough sleep.
  • Get support from people around you, or a coach.

Why sticking to it matters more than which diet you choose

In a 2005 trial in JAMA, Dansinger and colleagues randomly gave 160 adults with overweight or obesity one of four popular diets: Atkins, Zone, Weight Watchers or Ornish. After a year, about a third to a half of each group had dropped out, and average weight loss was modest, 2.1 to 3.3 kg (4.6 to 7.3 lb) depending on the diet. But the people who stuck to their diet more closely lost more weight, whichever diet it was. Weight loss was clearly linked with adherence and hardly at all with diet type.

The DIETFITS trial (Gardner and colleagues, 2018, JAMA) put 609 adults on either a healthy low-fat or a healthy low-carbohydrate diet for a year. Average weight loss was 5.3 kg (11.7 lb) and 6.0 kg (13.2 lb), a difference that was not statistically significant.

The International Society of Sports Nutrition reached the same view in its 2017 position stand on diets and body composition (Aragon and colleagues): a wide range of diets can work, and long-term success depends on how well you stick to the one you choose.

So the question is not "which diet works?" Most of them work if you follow them. The question is "which diet will I actually follow, and how do I keep following it?"

1. Choose a diet you could live with

Before you start, ask: could I eat like this for months? If the answer is no, pick something else.

  • Build it from food you like. A plan full of foods you dislike runs on willpower, and willpower runs out. Flexible dieting explains how to fit foods you enjoy into a fat loss diet.
  • Keep the deficit moderate. Losing about 0.5 to 1% of your body weight a week is a sensible pace for most people. Faster usually means more hunger, worse training and a diet that is harder to keep.
  • Fit it to your week. If you eat out every Friday, plan for it rather than pretending it will not happen.

If you have a health condition such as diabetes, are pregnant, take regular medication or have a history of disordered eating, speak to your doctor or GP before starting a diet.

2. Plan the hard moments in advance

Most diets do not fail at breakfast on a calm Tuesday. They fail at 9pm after a long day, at a birthday party, or when someone brings cakes into work.

Psychologists call the fix an implementation intention: an "if-then" plan made in advance. A 2006 meta-analysis by Gollwitzer and Sheeran pooled 94 tests of these plans, across all kinds of goals, and found a medium-to-large benefit for reaching the goal.

Write down your two or three hardest moments and a plan for each:

  • If I get home starving, then I will eat the protein snack I prepared before I start cooking.
  • If someone brings cakes into work, then I will have one and log it, or save it for after dinner.
  • If I go out for dinner, then I will choose a protein-based main and decide on drinks before I arrive.

3. Track something

Tracking keeps you honest and shows you where things slip. A 2011 systematic review by Burke and colleagues looked at 22 studies of self-monitoring in weight-loss programs, including food diaries, exercise records and regular weighing. People who monitored themselves more consistently lost more weight. The authors rated the evidence as weak because of how the studies were done, but the link was consistent.

You do not have to log every gram forever. Choose the level you can keep up:

  • Daily weight, judged as a weekly average.
  • Calories and protein, or at least protein.
  • A simple tick list of the few things that matter most, such as protein at each meal and a daily step target.

4. Turn the key actions into habits

A habit is something you do automatically in response to a cue, without having to decide each time. In a 2010 study, Lally and colleagues followed 96 volunteers who each picked one eating, drinking or activity habit to do daily in the same situation for 12 weeks. Among the 39 people whose data fitted the researchers' model well, it took a median of 66 days for the action to become close to fully automatic, with a range of 18 to 254 days. Missing a single day did not undo the progress.

What that means for you:

  • Expect it to take weeks or months, not the popular "21 days".
  • Tie each habit to a cue: protein with breakfast, a walk straight after lunch, packing tomorrow's lunch while dinner cooks.
  • Missing one day is fine. Just do not let one missed day become a missed week.

5. Drop the all-or-nothing rules

Thinking about food in black and white terms is a common reason diets fall apart. In a 2015 survey of 241 adults, Palascha and colleagues found that all-or-nothing thinking about food helped explain the link between restrained eating (deliberately holding back on food) and regaining weight. Questionnaire studies also link flexible control of eating with lower body weight and less binge eating, and rigid rules with more (Westenhöfer and colleagues, 1999). These studies show links, not proof of cause, but the pattern is consistent.

In practice:

  • One meal over target is a small blip. Go back to your plan at the next meal, not next Monday.
  • Swap "never" for "how much and how often".
  • Judge your week, not your day.

6. Keep hunger manageable

It is hard to stick to any diet while you are hungry all the time. Eating plenty of protein and fibre, choosing filling, high-volume foods, sleeping well and keeping the deficit moderate all help. How to stop feeling hungry on a diet goes through the research on each.

7. Plan your weekends

Weekends are where many good weeks come undone. In a study of people who had lost weight and kept it off, those who ate the same way all week were about 1.5 times as likely to stay within 2.3 kg (5 lb) of their weight over the next year as those who dieted more strictly on weekdays (Gorin and colleagues, 2004). Losing weight during the week and gaining at weekends shows how to fix that pattern.

8. Get support

Support from other people helps. In a 1999 trial by Wing and Jeffery, 166 people joined a weight-loss program either alone or with three friends or family members. Of those who joined alone and had the standard program, 76% completed it and 24% kept off all the weight they had lost over the following six months. Of those who joined with friends and also had extra social support, 95% completed it and 66% kept off all their weight loss.

Support can be a friend who diets with you, a partner who helps plan meals, or a coach who checks in every week.

When to change the diet instead of trying harder

Sometimes the problem is the diet, not you. Consider easing off, or taking a break at maintenance, if you notice:

  • constant hunger that stops you concentrating,
  • sleep getting worse,
  • training performance falling week after week,
  • thinking about food most of the day,
  • or episodes of eating that feel out of control.

If those episodes keep happening, or you are worried about your relationship with food, speak to your doctor or GP.

How coaching helps

Most people know what to eat. The hard part is doing it week after week, especially when life gets busy or results slow down.

With one-to-one coaching from CoachAk, your nutrition targets and training program sit in a private app. Your coach can set a few daily habits that you tick off each day. Each weekly check-in takes about three minutes and covers your weight, training and nutrition adherence, steps, sleep, energy, hunger and stress. Your coach replies with written feedback on what went well, what to change and why, adjusts your plan when it is not working, and you can message your coach directly when a hard moment comes up between check-ins.

If you want help building a diet you can actually keep, apply for coaching.

Share this article:

WhatsAppFacebookXEmail

Free newsletter

New articles, straight to your inbox

Get new CoachAk articles by email: training, nutrition, contest prep and health, explained plainly.

Free. Unsubscribe any time. Your email address is used only for this newsletter, is never sold, and is not shared with anyone else unless the law requires it. Privacy policy