How to Get the Most Out of Online Coaching

By CoachAk · · 6 min read

How to get the most out of online coaching comes down to one idea: your coach can only coach what they can see. They never stand next to you in the kitchen or the gym, so the plan is only as good as the information you send back. Honest check-ins, steady logging, useful photos and notes, and good questions do more for your results than any clever change to your program.

This is the client's side of the relationship, for anyone about to start with a coach or already working with one.

How to get the most out of online coaching: the short answer

  • Tell the truth in every check-in, especially in the bad weeks. A missed target is information, not a failure.
  • Log every day: your morning weight, your workouts and the habits your coach sets. Gaps are harder to coach than bad numbers.
  • Make photos and notes useful: same conditions every time, and a line of context when something unusual happened.
  • Ask why. Understanding the plan makes it easier to follow and teaches you to run it yourself one day.
  • Give each change time before judging it, and change one thing at a time.
  • Flag problems early: pain, illness, a new medicine, a stressful month. Small problems are easy to plan around.

Be honest in every check-in

The check-in is the whole feedback loop. Your coach decides whether to change your calories, steps or training from what you report. If the report is rosier than the week, the decision will be wrong.

It is easy to get this wrong without meaning to. In a classic 1992 study in the New England Journal of Medicine, Lichtman and colleagues checked the reports of people who said they could not lose weight on low calories against careful laboratory measurements. On average, they under-reported what they ate by 47% and over-reported their physical activity by 51%. The point is not that people lie. Recording food accurately is genuinely hard, and small things such as cooking oil, drinks and extra bites are easy to miss.

So report what happened, not what you meant to do:

  • "Hit my calories Monday to Thursday, then about two meals out over the weekend" is far more useful than "nutrition 8 out of 10".
  • If you missed sessions, say how many and why.
  • If you are unsure how accurate your tracking was, say that too.

Reporting helps in its own right. A 2016 meta-analysis by Harkin and colleagues in Psychological Bulletin, pooling 138 studies with 19,951 people, found that monitoring your progress makes you more likely to reach your goal, and more so when progress is recorded or reported to someone else. A weekly check-in does both, but only if it is honest.

Log every day, especially the bad days

Your coach looks for trends, and trends need data.

  • Weigh yourself every morning, after the toilet and before eating or drinking, and judge the weekly average rather than any single day. Water, salt, carbohydrate and food in your gut move the scale from day to day; how to read the scale explains why.
  • Log every workout: the weights, the reps and how hard it felt. That lets your coach see whether you are progressing, stalling or getting tired, and comment on specific sessions.
  • Tick off your daily habits honestly. A habit you never manage is a sign the habit needs changing, not that you need to hide it.

The days you least want to log, after a big meal or a poor session, are often the most useful. One missing week makes the next decision a guess.

Make your photos and notes useful

Photos. If you send progress photos, take them in the same place, light, poses and time of day each time, ideally first thing in the morning. Different lighting can make the same body look leaner or softer, which means a coach comparing them is comparing the lighting. How to take progress photos shows a simple setup.

Notes. A line of context saves a lot of guessing. Worth mentioning:

  • travel, a holiday, a wedding or a night out;
  • a cold, a stomach bug or a bad week of sleep;
  • a new job, a house move or a stressful week;
  • for women, where you are in your menstrual cycle, if you track it, since water retention can move the scale;
  • a sore joint, or an exercise that does not feel right.

A short, specific note beats a long, vague one. "Knee aches on the last set of lunges" can be acted on. "Legs felt off" is harder.

Ask questions, and ask why

A good coach explains their decisions, and you get more from coaching when you understand them. If you do not see why your calories went down, or why an exercise was swapped, ask. Understanding the reason makes it easier to stick to the change, and it is how you learn to make the same decisions yourself later.

Ask the practical questions too: what to order at a restaurant, what to do when the gym is packed, whether a swap is fine. A quick message before you guess is better than a week of guessing. If you are unsure about your technique on a lift, a short video lets your coach see it for themselves.

Give each change time

Most of the progress in coaching comes from small changes, repeated and judged over weeks. That only works if the plan stays still long enough to read.

  • Do not change several things at once. If you add cardio, cut snacks and start a new program in the same week, nobody can tell what worked.
  • Judge a change over a couple of weeks, not a couple of days. One heavy morning is usually water.
  • Do not add extras on your own. Extra sessions, a crash day or a new supplement can blur the picture. If you want to do more, ask first.
  • Expect slow, real rates. On a cut, losing about 0.5 to 1% of your body weight a week is a sensible pace for keeping muscle. Muscle gain is slower still, and hard to see from week to week.

What quietly slows progress

Most stalls in coaching are not about the plan. Common culprits:

  • Weekend drift. Five good days and two loose ones can cancel out a deficit.
  • Hidden extras: cooking oil, sauces, drinks and "just a bite" that never get logged.
  • Skipping check-ins in bad weeks. The weeks you want to hide are the weeks your coach most needs to see.
  • Chasing the daily number, and changing things after one bad weigh-in.
  • Program hopping, or doing your own sessions on top of the plan.
  • Sleep and stress, which affect hunger, energy and training. If they are poor, say so.
  • Comparing yourself with other people, whose starting point, history and timeline you do not know.

Know when it is not a coaching question

A coach plans training and food. Some things need a professional instead. If you have pain that does not settle, an injury, a health condition, symptoms that worry you, or a history of disordered eating, or if you start or change a medicine, speak to your doctor or GP, and tell your coach so the plan can work around it. Keep taking any prescribed medicine as prescribed, whatever your diet or training plan, and raise any questions about it with your prescriber.

How coaching with CoachAk helps

Everything above is easier when it all lives in one place. With one-to-one coaching from CoachAk, your training program and nutrition targets are in a private app, alongside your daily weight with a smoothed trend, a training log with your personal bests and your coach's comments, and the daily habits your coach sets. Each week you send a check-in that takes about three minutes: weight, training and nutrition adherence, steps, sleep, energy, hunger, stress and digestion notes, with optional body measurements and photos. Your coach replies with written feedback and adjusts your plan, and between check-ins you can message directly, with photos and voice notes, or send a form-check video for feedback.

If you are starting out, what to expect in your first month of online coaching walks through the early weeks. If you want a coach who reads every check-in, apply for coaching.

Share this article:

WhatsAppFacebookXEmail

Free newsletter

New articles, straight to your inbox

Get new CoachAk articles by email: training, nutrition, contest prep and health, explained plainly.

Free. Unsubscribe any time. Your email address is used only for this newsletter, is never sold, and is not shared with anyone else unless the law requires it. Privacy policy