Volume Eating: How to Feel Full on Fewer Calories
By CoachAk · · 6 min read
Volume eating means building your meals from foods that give you a lot to eat for few calories, mostly foods rich in water and fibre, so a calorie deficit feels less like a diet. Researchers call these foods low in "energy density", and much of the evidence comes from Barbara Rolls's group at Penn State. Here is how volume eating works, what the studies show, and how to do it without the common mistakes.
Volume eating: the short answer
- Energy density is calories per gram of food. The lower it is, the more food you get for the same calories.
- In studies, lowering the energy density of meals cut the calories people ate without leaving them less full.
- Your main tools are vegetables, fruit, broth-based soups, salads, potatoes and lean protein, with less fat added in cooking.
- Keep protein high and do not cut fat out. Volume alone does not make a good diet.
- Drinks are not volume eating. Juice, smoothies and alcohol add calories without filling you up much.
What is energy density?
The US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention (CDC) define energy density as "the amount of energy or calories in a particular weight of food". Each part of a food adds a different amount:
| Part of food | Calories per gram |
|---|---|
| Water | 0 |
| Fibre | About 1.5 to 2.5 |
| Protein | 4 |
| Carbohydrate | 4 |
| Fat | 9 |
So foods full of water and fibre, like vegetables, fruit and soup, are low in energy density. Foods that are dry or fatty, like crackers, crisps, chocolate and pastries, are high. Grapes and raisins are the same food, but drying out the water packs the same calories into a much smaller handful.
How to check: UK food labels show calories per 100 g. The lower that number, the more you can eat for the calories. Compare similar foods side by side and you will quickly learn which ones are worth their space on your plate.
What the research on volume eating shows
The CDC's research summary on low-energy-dense foods brings together several of the key studies:
- Water in food fills you; water with food does not. Rolls and colleagues found that turning a casserole into a soup by adding water increased fullness and reduced calories eaten. Drinking a glass of water with the same casserole did not.
- Starting with a salad helps. People who began lunch with a low-energy-dense salad ate fewer calories at that meal and felt just as full.
- Lowering energy density cut more calories than shrinking portions. In a study by Rolls, Roe and Meengs, cutting the energy density of meals by 25% reduced the calories people ate by 24%. Cutting portion sizes by 25% reduced them by only 10%.
- Soup twice a day for a year. In a year-long trial by Rolls and colleagues, people who ate two servings a day of low-energy-dense soup lost about 7.2 kg (15.9 lb), against 4.8 kg (10.6 lb) for those who ate two servings of dry snacks, about 50% more.
The reason this works is simple. Smaller portions of the same food leave you looking at a half-empty plate. Lower-energy-density meals let you keep the plate full.
How to build a volume eating meal
You do not need special recipes. Adjust what you already eat:
- Start with protein. Chicken, fish, lean mince, eggs, Greek yoghurt, tofu or beans. Protein is the most filling macronutrient and protects your muscle on a diet. See high-protein diet for weight loss.
- Fill about half the plate with vegetables or salad. Most vegetables are mostly water and fibre.
- Add a starchy carbohydrate that holds water. Potatoes are naturally full of water, and rice, pasta, porridge oats and dried beans soak it up as they cook.
- Measure the fat you cook with. Oils, butter and dressings add calories with almost no volume.
- Bulk out what you already make. Grated courgette, mushrooms, onions, peppers or spinach stretch mince dishes, omelettes, stews and pasta sauces.
- Open with a broth-based soup or a salad when you know a meal will be tempting.
Volume eating swaps
| Instead of | Try |
|---|---|
| Dried fruit | Fresh berries, grapes or an apple |
| Fruit juice | A piece of whole fruit and a glass of water |
| Granola | Porridge cooked with water or milk, topped with berries |
| A creamy pasta sauce | A tomato-based sauce packed with vegetables |
| Chips fried in oil | Oven-baked potato wedges with a little oil |
| A full plate of rice | Half rice, half cauliflower rice or extra vegetables |
| Cheese and crackers | Cottage cheese with cucumber, peppers and cherry tomatoes |
| A pastry or pie for lunch | A jacket potato with beans or tuna and a side salad |
None of these foods are banned. The point is to spend most of your calories where they fill you up, and to keep room for the foods you really enjoy.
Common volume eating mistakes
Forgetting protein. A huge salad with little protein fills your stomach for an hour and then leaves you hungry. Build every meal around a protein source first.
Cutting fat right out. Fat is needed for health. The cutting guides on this site keep fat at about 15 to 30% of calories, in line with a 2014 review of contest prep nutrition by Helms and colleagues. Use it on purpose rather than by accident.
Adding fibre too fast. The NHS recommends adults aim for 30 g of fibre a day. Jumping from very little to a lot overnight can bring wind and bloating, so build up over a couple of weeks. Gut health for lifters has more on this.
Drinking your calories. The CDC notes that drinks are unlikely to make you feel full, even when they contain calories. Juice, smoothies, milky coffees and alcohol all add calories, but they do not satisfy hunger the way food does.
Relying on sweeteners. In 2023 the World Health Organization issued a conditional recommendation against using non-sugar sweeteners for weight control, because its review found no long-term benefit for body fat. It does not apply to people who already have diabetes. WHO suggests fruit and unsweetened food and drinks instead.
Using it when you need to gain weight. Volume eating is a tool for a diet. On a bulk, or if you already struggle to eat enough, more energy-dense foods are often the easier way to hit your calories.
Does volume eating work on its own?
Volume eating is a way to make a calorie deficit easier, not a replacement for one. You can still overeat low-energy-dense foods, and a meal of vegetables drowned in oil is not a volume meal. It works best alongside the basics: a moderate deficit, enough protein, good sleep and a way of tracking what you eat. How to stop feeling hungry on a diet covers the other tools that help.
If you find yourself eating huge amounts of low-calorie food to avoid "real" meals, feel anxious about food, or have a history of disordered eating, speak to your doctor or GP. In the UK, the eating disorder charity Beat also offers support.
How coaching helps
Knowing which foods are filling is one thing. Turning that into meals you enjoy, at a calorie target that actually moves the scale, is another. With one-to-one coaching from CoachAk, your calorie, macro and step targets are set in a private app. Each week you send a check-in of about three minutes covering your weight, nutrition adherence, steps, sleep, energy, hunger and stress, along with digestion notes. Your coach reads it and replies with written feedback on what to change, whether that is more volume at the meal you struggle with, a different calorie split or a slower rate of loss. You can message your coach between check-ins, with photos of your meals if you want a second opinion.
If you want a diet that keeps you full, apply for coaching.
Free newsletter
New articles, straight to your inbox
Get new CoachAk articles by email: training, nutrition, contest prep and health, explained plainly.
Free. Unsubscribe any time. Your email address is used only for this newsletter, is never sold, and is not shared with anyone else unless the law requires it. Privacy policy