When to Change Macros: Signs to Adjust or Wait
By CoachAk · · 7 min read
The answer to when to change macros is usually "later than you think". Give any new set of numbers two to three weeks (a little longer on a bulk), judge them by your weekly average weight rather than single weigh-ins, and only change them when the trend has been off target for that long while you were actually hitting them. Then make one small change, of about 100 to 200 calories a day, and wait again. Here is how to tell a real signal from noise, on a cut and on a bulk.
When to change macros: the short answer
| What your weekly average shows (over 2 to 3 weeks) | What to do |
|---|---|
| Moving at your target rate | Change nothing |
| Flat on a cut, or flat on a bulk | Check you are hitting your numbers, then take away (cut) or add (bulk) about 100 to 200 calories a day |
| Losing faster than about 1% of body weight a week | Add about 100 to 200 calories a day |
| Gaining faster than your monthly target on a bulk | Take away about 100 to 200 calories a day |
| On target, but training, hunger or energy is suffering | Look at how your calories are split first; if it carries on, slow the rate |
Protein usually stays where it is. The changes come from carbohydrate and fat.
Why you should wait at least two weeks
Your daily weight moves for reasons that have nothing to do with fat or muscle: salt, how much food is in your gut, a hard leg session, poor sleep, and for many women, the menstrual cycle. Carbohydrate is a big one. Muscle stores at least 3 g of water with every gram of glycogen, its stored carbohydrate (Fernández-Elías and colleagues, 2015), so a change in carbohydrate can move the scale by a kilogram or more in a few days.
That is why the first week of any change tells you very little. Start a cut and the scale often drops quickly as glycogen and water fall. Start a bulk and it often jumps for the same reason in reverse. Neither is your real rate.
To get a usable signal:
- Weigh every morning, after the toilet and before eating or drinking.
- Average each week.
- Compare weekly averages over two to three weeks, ignoring the first week after a change.
- If you have periods, compare the same phase of your cycle where you can.
How to read the scale explains the daily swings in more detail.
First, check you are actually hitting your numbers
Before changing your macros, check whether the old ones were really followed. Changing numbers you have not been hitting just moves the target further away.
Under-counting is very common and is not about honesty. In a 1992 study in the New England Journal of Medicine, Lichtman and colleagues found that people who believed they could not lose weight on low calories under-reported what they ate by 47% on average.
Ask yourself honestly:
- Did you log everything, including oils, sauces, drinks and bites?
- Did weekends look like weekdays?
- Did your steps stay roughly the same?
- Were those weeks fairly normal, without illness, travel, a holiday or a very stressful stretch?
If the answer to any of these is no, keep the same macros and fix that first. How to count macros covers the usual logging mistakes.
Signs it is time to change macros on a cut
In their 2014 evidence-based recommendations for natural bodybuilders, Helms and colleagues advise losing about 0.5 to 1% of your body weight a week to hold on to muscle. The leaner you are, the closer to 0.5% you should be.
Change your macros when, over two to three weeks of good adherence:
- Your weekly average has stopped falling. Take out about 100 to 200 calories a day, or add some daily steps instead.
- You are losing faster than about 1% a week. Add about 100 to 200 calories back, usually as carbohydrate.
- Your training is falling apart, with lifts dropping across the board, or hunger and low energy are making the diet hard to stick to. Your total may be fine, but the split may need to change: moving some calories from fat to carbohydrate can help training. If you are losing weight steadily and still struggling, that is a sign to slow the rate.
For scale, 25 g of carbohydrate is 100 calories and 10 g of fat is 90 calories. Macros for cutting shows how the numbers are set in the first place.
Signs it is time to change macros on a bulk
On a bulk, you are aiming for a slow, steady rise. Common targets, as a share of body weight per month:
| Training experience | Target gain per month |
|---|---|
| Beginner (under about 1 year) | 1 to 1.5% |
| Intermediate (about 1 to 3 years) | 0.5 to 1% |
| Advanced (more than about 3 years) | up to 0.5% |
Because those rates are small, it takes a little longer to see them. A 75 kg (165 lb) intermediate lifter is aiming for about 0.4 to 0.75 kg (about 0.8 to 1.7 lb) a month, or roughly 0.1 to 0.2 kg (0.2 to 0.4 lb) a week, which daily water swings can easily hide. Give a bulk two to four weeks before judging it.
- Weight flat, or rising more slowly than your target? Add about 100 to 200 calories a day, mostly from carbohydrate or fat.
- Weight rising faster than your target, or your waist rising quickly while your lifts barely move? Take away about 100 to 200 calories a day.
Why your macros need to change over time
Even if you do everything right, a set of macros will not stay right for long.
On a cut, your maintenance falls. A smaller body burns less energy. A 2011 paper in The Lancet by Hall and colleagues gives a rule of thumb for an average overweight adult: each 24 calories a day of intake is worth about 1 kg (2.2 lb) of eventual body weight. Turned around, after losing 5 kg (11 lb), your maintenance is likely about 120 calories a day lower. The same numbers that worked in week one may only hold your weight by week ten.
On a bulk, your maintenance rises as you get heavier, so a long bulk usually needs small increases along the way.
That is why a plateau after many weeks of steady progress is normal. It does not mean your metabolism is broken. It means your numbers have caught up with your new body.
How much to change
There is no tested rule for exact adjustment sizes, so this is common coaching practice:
- Change one thing at a time, so you know what made the difference.
- Make it small: about 100 to 200 calories a day, roughly a small snack.
- Keep protein the same. On a cut, aim to keep it towards the top of 1.6 to 2.2 g per kg of body weight a day.
- Wait two to three weeks before judging the change.
Big jumps feel productive, but they make it harder to see what is working. On a cut, they also bring more hunger and poorer training.
When not to change your macros
- After one bad weigh-in, or a heavy weekend.
- In the first week of a new diet or bulk.
- Around your period, if you know your weight rises then.
- During illness, travel or a very stressful week. Wait until things settle.
- When the plan is working but feels hard. Some hunger on a cut and some fullness on a bulk are normal.
The exceptions are planned changes: ending a cut, starting a diet break or moving into a bulk. Those are changes to your goal, not reactions to the scale.
If you feel unwell, are losing weight much faster than planned, or your periods stop or become irregular while dieting, speak to your doctor or GP. If you have a health condition such as diabetes, or take regular medication, speak to your doctor before changing your diet.
How coaching helps
Most people change their macros too early, too much, or in response to the wrong number. With one-to-one coaching from CoachAk, you log your weight daily and the app shows it as a smoothed trend, so one odd morning does not hijack the plan. Your calorie and macro targets sit in the app, and each weekly check-in takes about three minutes, covering your weight, training and nutrition adherence, steps, sleep, energy, hunger and stress. Your coach replies with written feedback on what changes next week and why, and adjusts your targets when the trend, not the mood of the week, says so.
If you want someone else making these calls with you, apply for coaching.
Free newsletter
New articles, straight to your inbox
Get new CoachAk articles by email: training, nutrition, contest prep and health, explained plainly.
Free. Unsubscribe any time. Your email address is used only for this newsletter, is never sold, and is not shared with anyone else unless the law requires it. Privacy policy