How to Stop Snacking at Night

By CoachAk · · 7 min read

If you are wondering how to stop snacking at night, the answer is to plan for the evening rather than fight it. Your appetite naturally rises as the day goes on, and tiredness, the sofa and the television do the rest. Eating enough earlier in the day, saving some of your calories for a snack you have chosen, changing the cues that set off the habit and getting to bed on time work far better than relying on willpower at 10pm.

How to stop snacking at night: the short answer

  • Expect evenings to be harder. In a laboratory study, hunger peaked around 8pm and was lowest around 8am, whatever people had eaten.
  • Eat enough, and enough protein, earlier in the day, so you do not arrive at the evening starving.
  • Save calories for a planned evening snack if evenings are your weak spot. Total calories matter far more than the time you eat them.
  • Eat at the table, not in front of a screen. Distracted eating makes people eat more, at that meal and later.
  • Change the cues: a set time the kitchen closes, snacks out of sight, and an if-then plan for your usual trigger.
  • Go to bed earlier. In a trial, people who slept about an hour longer ate about 270 calories a day less than a comparison group.

Why evenings are the danger zone

Your body clock turns appetite up. In a 2013 study in Obesity, Scheer, Morris and Shea kept 12 healthy adults in a laboratory for 13 days, spreading meals and sleep evenly around the clock so they could see the body's own rhythm. Hunger was lowest at about 8am and highest at about 8pm, a swing of about 17%. Appetite for sweet, salty and starchy foods followed the same pattern. The authors suggest this evening peak may have evolved to encourage a bigger meal before the overnight fast.

Busy days push food later. If you skip breakfast, grab a small lunch and train after work, much of your day's hunger is waiting for you in the evening.

Evenings are full of cues. The sofa, the television, the end of a long day and the feeling that you have "earned" something are classic triggers. When a habit is tied to a time and a place, the time and the place start the craving. How to stop sugar cravings explains how those links form and how they fade.

Staying up late adds hours to eat in. Short sleep goes with eating more, as the trials further down show, and every extra hour awake is another chance to open the cupboard.

Does eating at night make you gain fat?

Not by itself. What matters is how much you eat across the day. In a 2022 trial by Liu and colleagues (New England Journal of Medicine), 139 adults with obesity were set the same calorie targets and either ate only between 8am and 4pm or ate whenever they liked. After a year, the difference in weight loss between the two groups was not statistically significant.

So the problem with night snacking is the extra calories it adds on top of a full day of eating, not the clock. That is good news: a snack in the evening, planned into your day, is perfectly fine.

1. Eat enough earlier in the day

Arriving at the evening hungry makes everything harder. Build breakfast and lunch around protein, which is the most filling macronutrient, and add plenty of vegetables, fruit and other high-volume foods. High-protein diet for weight loss shows how.

If you train in the evening, have a proper meal or snack in the afternoon so you are not facing both a workout and a long gap before dinner.

2. Plan an evening snack on purpose

If evenings are when you struggle, move some of your calories there. Eat slightly smaller meals earlier and keep a couple of hundred calories for a snack after dinner. A 2014 review of nutrition for natural bodybuilders by Helms and colleagues suggests 3 to 6 meals a day and notes that changing meal timing and frequency appears to make little difference to fat loss or muscle retention, so arrange your meals to suit your day.

Good evening snacks are filling, quick and portioned:

  • Greek yoghurt or skyr with berries
  • Cottage cheese with fruit or on crackers
  • A protein shake made with milk
  • A bowl of cereal with milk, measured
  • A piece of fruit and a few squares of chocolate

Decide what it is before the evening starts. A planned snack is a choice; an unplanned one usually turns into a second dinner.

3. Eat it at the table, not in front of a screen

In a 2013 meta-analysis of 24 studies (American Journal of Clinical Nutrition), Robinson and colleagues found that eating while distracted made people eat moderately more at that meal, and even more later on. Making a meal more memorable reduced how much people ate later.

So put your evening snack in a bowl, sit at the table and eat it without your phone or the television. Eating straight from the packet on the sofa is exactly the situation in which a portion disappears without you noticing.

4. Change the cues

Night snacking is usually a habit, and habits run on cues. Change the cue and the habit weakens.

  • Set a time the kitchen closes, and do something that signals the day's eating is over: brush your teeth, make a hot drink, or leave the kitchen.
  • Keep snack foods out of sight, or out of the house. Buy single portions rather than family packs.
  • Make an if-then plan for your main trigger: "If I sit down to watch television, then I will make a cup of tea." Spell out the situation and the response in advance, rather than deciding in the moment.
  • Give your hands something to do if eating is linked to boredom: a walk, a shower, a call, reading in another room.

Expect it to take a while. In a 2010 study by Lally and colleagues (European Journal of Social Psychology), a new daily habit, such as eating fruit with lunch, took a median of 66 days to feel automatic (the middle value: half the people took less, half took more), with a range of 18 to 254 days. Missing a single day made little difference, so one slip in the evening is not a reason to give up.

5. Go to bed

Sleep is one of the most underrated tools for night snacking. In a 2022 trial in JAMA Internal Medicine, Tasali and colleagues worked with 80 adults with overweight who usually slept less than 6.5 hours a night. After individual advice on sleep habits, the sleep group slept about 1.2 hours a night longer than the control group over two weeks and ate about 270 calories a day less.

A 2017 meta-analysis by Al Khatib and colleagues found the reverse: after partial sleep loss, people ate about 385 calories a day more. The American Academy of Sleep Medicine recommends at least 7 hours a night for adults. Going to bed earlier also simply cuts the hours in which you can snack. How to stop feeling hungry on a diet covers sleep and the other things that turn appetite up.

When it is more than a habit

Some night eating is not a habit but a health problem. If you regularly eat a large share of your food late at night, wake up in the night to eat, or have episodes where you eat a very large amount and feel out of control, speak to your doctor or GP. Binge eating disorder is a recognised eating disorder, and the US National Eating Disorders Association lists night eating syndrome, which it describes as excessive night-time eating, among its "other specified" eating disorders. Both need proper support rather than a stricter diet. In the UK, the eating disorder charity Beat also offers help.

If you have diabetes or take medicine that affects your blood sugar, speak to your doctor or GP before changing when or how much you eat in the evening.

How coaching helps

Night snacking rarely has a single cause, so it helps when someone looks at the whole day. With one-to-one coaching from CoachAk, your calorie and macro targets are set in a private app, and your coach can set daily habits for you to tick off, such as a kitchen closing time or a bedtime. Each week you send a check-in of about three minutes covering your weight, nutrition adherence, sleep, energy, hunger and stress, and your coach replies with written feedback on what to change, whether that is a bigger lunch, a planned evening snack or an earlier night. You can message your coach directly between check-ins.

If you want a plan that works with your evenings rather than against them, apply for coaching.

Share this article:

WhatsAppFacebookXEmail

Free newsletter

New articles, straight to your inbox

Get new CoachAk articles by email: training, nutrition, contest prep and health, explained plainly.

Free. Unsubscribe any time. Your email address is used only for this newsletter, is never sold, and is not shared with anyone else unless the law requires it. Privacy policy