How to Stop Sugar Cravings When You're Dieting

By CoachAk · · 6 min read

If you want to know how to stop sugar cravings, the encouraging news is that they usually fade as a diet goes on. You can help them fade faster by eating sweet foods less often (rather than banning them), keeping your meals filling and regular, sleeping enough, and having a plan for the moment a craving hits. Here is what the research says about each, and why willpower alone is the wrong tool.

How to stop sugar cravings: the short answer

  • A craving is not hunger. Hunger can be satisfied by any food; a craving wants one particular food.
  • Cravings tend to drop on longer diets. A meta-analysis of diets lasting at least 12 weeks found they fell, and a 2020 review notes that most of the drop comes in the first weeks.
  • Eat sweet foods less often, not just in smaller amounts. In one large trial, how often people ate a craved food was linked to their cravings; how much they ate was not.
  • Do not ban sugar outright. Rigid dieting rules go with more binge eating than flexible ones.
  • Sleep at least 7 hours. Short sleep raises appetite, especially for sweet and starchy foods.
  • Move when a craving hits. A 15-minute brisk walk reduced chocolate cravings in a small study.

Is it a craving or hunger?

In a 2020 review in Current Nutrition Reports, the psychologist Adrian Meule defines a food craving as "an intense desire to eat a particular type of food". Hunger is different: any food will do. You can have a craving without being hungry at all, or have both at once.

A quick check: if a plain meal, say chicken and rice or eggs on toast, sounds fine right now, you are probably hungry. Eat a proper meal. If only chocolate will do, it is a craving, and the strategies below will help more than another meal would.

Is sugar addictive?

Probably not in the way people mean. In a 2016 review in the European Journal of Nutrition, Westwater, Fletcher and Ziauddeen found "little evidence to support sugar addiction in humans". In rats, addiction-like behaviour such as bingeing appeared only when sugar was given on and off, and the authors put that down to intermittent access to tasty food rather than anything special about sugar's effect on the brain.

That is good news. Cravings look much more like learned habits than chemical dependence. A common explanation is conditioning: cravings become tied to the times, places, moods and routines in which you usually eat that food. Habits can be unlearned.

Do cravings get worse on a diet?

At first, sometimes. Over time, usually not.

  • Short-term: in Meule's review, cutting out one specific food for a short time (1 to 14 days in the studies) tended to increase cravings for it, mostly in people who already craved it a lot or dieted strictly.
  • Longer term: a meta-analysis by Kahathuduwa and colleagues (Obesity Reviews, 2017) pooled eight studies in which people with obesity cut calories for at least 12 weeks. Cravings fell overall, including cravings for sweet foods. Meule notes that the drop mostly happens in the first weeks and does not appear to bounce back later.

So if the first fortnight of a diet is full of cravings, that is common, and it tends to ease.

1. Eat sweet foods less often

This is the most useful finding for anyone dieting. In the POUNDS Lost trial, Apolzan and colleagues (Obesity, 2017) followed 367 overweight and obese adults on a two-year weight-loss diet. People who ate their craved foods less often saw their cravings for those foods drop. Changes in the amount they ate were not linked to cravings.

It is an observational finding within a trial, so it shows a link rather than proof. But it suggests that a small chocolate bar every evening may keep the habit, and the craving, alive. Having a proper portion two or three times a week, at times you choose, may let the craving fade.

2. Do not ban sugar completely

Strict rules tend to backfire. In a 1999 paper drawing on a large weight-loss program and a survey of 1,838 adults, Westenhoefer, Stunkard and Pudel compared two styles of dieting. Rigid control, an all-or-nothing approach, went with a higher body mass index and more frequent and severe binge eating. Flexible control, a more give-and-take approach, went with less binge eating, a lower body mass index and a better chance of losing weight over the year-long program. That is an association, not proof of cause, but it is a good reason to avoid absolute bans.

So plan sweet foods into your day's calories rather than forbidding them. For health, the NHS says adults should have no more than 30 g of free sugars a day, roughly seven sugar cubes. Free sugars are those added to food and drink, plus honey, syrups and fruit juice. Sugar in whole fruit, vegetables and milk does not count, so fruit is a sensible go-to when you want something sweet.

3. Do not let yourself get ravenous

Apolzan and colleagues discuss one explanation: cravings may form when hunger is repeatedly paired with a particular food. If you skip meals, arrive home starving and reach for biscuits, that pairing gets stronger every time.

Regular meals built around protein and filling, high-volume foods break that loop. See high-protein diet for weight loss and volume eating for how to build them.

4. Protect your sleep

In a 2004 study by Spiegel and colleagues (Annals of Internal Medicine), 12 young men spent two nights with only 4 hours in bed. Their hunger rose by 24%, with the biggest increase in appetite for sweets, salty snacks and starchy foods. The American Academy of Sleep Medicine recommends adults get at least 7 hours a night. If your cravings are worst after a short night, that fits what this study found. Sleep and muscle growth has practical ways to improve it.

5. Move when a craving hits

In a 2009 study in Appetite, Taylor and Oliver asked 25 regular chocolate eaters to go without chocolate for three days. On one day they went for a 15-minute brisk walk, and on another they rested. The walk reduced their urges to eat chocolate. It was a small study, but a walk costs nothing and adds to your steps.

Other ways to put space between the urge and the food:

  • Change rooms or activities, especially if the craving is tied to the sofa and the television.
  • Have a hot drink or brush your teeth after dinner, as a signal that eating is done.
  • Keep sweets out of sight, or out of the house, so a craving has to be acted on rather than just reached for.

What about sweeteners?

Swapping a sugary drink for a diet one cuts calories. But in 2023 the World Health Organization issued a conditional recommendation against using non-sugar sweeteners for weight control, after its review found no long-term benefit for body fat. It does not apply to people who already have diabetes. WHO suggests fruit and unsweetened food and drinks instead. Use sweeteners as a stepping stone if they help, not as the whole plan.

When to speak to your doctor

If you have diabetes or another medical condition, or you are pregnant, speak to your doctor or GP before changing your diet. If cravings turn into episodes where you feel out of control around food, or you have a history of disordered eating, speak to your doctor or GP. In the UK, the eating disorder charity Beat also offers support.

How coaching helps

Cravings are personal: they turn up at particular times, in particular places and on particular kinds of days. With one-to-one coaching from CoachAk, your calorie and macro targets sit in a private app, and your coach can set daily habits for you to tick off, such as a walk after dinner or a bedtime. Each week you send a check-in of about three minutes covering your weight, nutrition adherence, sleep, energy, hunger and stress, and your coach replies with written feedback on what to change. Between check-ins you can message your coach directly, which helps on the evenings when a craving feels louder than your plan.

If you want a coach to help you through the cravings, apply for coaching.

Share this article:

WhatsAppFacebookXEmail

Free newsletter

New articles, straight to your inbox

Get new CoachAk articles by email: training, nutrition, contest prep and health, explained plainly.

Free. Unsubscribe any time. Your email address is used only for this newsletter, is never sold, and is not shared with anyone else unless the law requires it. Privacy policy